When we examine Quebec’s relationship with the Westminster system, it’s worth reflecting on history. France, from which many Quebecers descend, abolished its monarchy during the French Revolution. King Louis XVI was executed in 1793, and the First French Republic was born. In that context, Quebecers may justifiably feel conflicted being governed under a system rooted in monarchy—a system their ancestors once rejected with force and conviction.
This raises a deeper point: Quebec’s push for independence has always been about more than money. It’s about self-determination, cultural identity, and the kind of governance they believe in. Many Albertan independence advocates, by contrast, often frame their cause strictly in financial terms. While economic frustration is valid, when arguments boil down only to “we pay too much,” it can come across as greed rather than principle—and that weakens the message.
One of the more thoughtful voices in the Albertan autonomy movement is Ben Trudeau, founder of Alberta Free. Despite the coincidence of his last name—one that may raise eyebrows given Canadian political history—his ideas are grounded in legitimate concerns. Personally, I prefer to refer to Alberta as The Autonomous Canadian Province of Alberta, because that’s the direction I believe it’s heading.
Why Fiscal Independence Is Step One
I don’t see a future federal Conservative government reversing these tensions unless it aggressively pursues an austerity agenda—which may alienate Quebec, where social spending and centralized redistribution are more culturally embedded. For Alberta to truly shift toward autonomy, it must gain control of its financial narrative. It’s astonishing that Albertans still need convincing when it comes to creating their own pension plan. Public pensions—regardless of one’s belief in them—are unsustainable pyramid schemes. They rely on perpetual growth, borrowing, and inflation, all of which are increasingly driven by climate-based policies like ESG and Net Zero, used to justify endless monetary expansion to bail out bankrupt public systems.
When ESG inevitably fails, it will simply be replaced by another slogan. The so-called “socialist utopia” is already functionally dead. Most of Western Europe is financially insolvent. Canada survives for now because the global currency markets still perceive value in its fiat currency—despite disorderly fiscal balance sheets. As a believer in God, I personally thank Him for that grace. But history tells us: even God’s people are not exempt from hardship. Sometimes, hardship is what reveals His power.
Culture, Religion, and Governance
A fundamental problem in Canada—and much of the West—is spiritual. We are not just turning away from Christianity; we are importing cultures that often reject it entirely. Historically, strong atheist nations enforce strict rules: in Japan, order is prized; in Singapore, corporal punishment is still legal. Meanwhile, Western democracies spiral into censorship, entitlement, and decay—pushing state control over personal responsibility.
Alberta, despite its strengths, lacks full autonomy because it still relies on systems controlled by Ottawa: the RCMP, centralized pensions, and federal transfer payments. The NDP strongholds in Alberta’s urban centers are unlikely to go quietly. History shows that left-leaning parties will defend government dependency at all costs—even against the economic interests of the broader population.
Quebec, ironically, is more culturally assertive and more outspoken on key social issues than most English-speaking provinces. While Quebec’s policies aren’t always aligned with my own values, their political boldness is a model for how Alberta might move forward—if it can break its emotional and fiscal dependence on Ottawa.
Faith and the Role of Christians
The Kingdom of God is not built on government policy—it’s built within us. Jesus taught us to love, to forgive, and to be courageous. He also warned us, in Luke 22:36, to be prepared and responsible. As Christians, we don’t build the Kingdom of Heaven through force, but we must be honest: we are living in a fallen world, among systems that often replace God with government.
A welfare state, once entrenched, makes all of us complicit in theft. The line between governance and control becomes blurry. In such a system, it’s no longer about right or wrong—it’s about who can manipulate the system more effectively. If Alberta is to secede, or even become truly autonomous, it must do so deliberately and wisely, not emotionally or impulsively. That begins with spiritual clarity, not political slogans.
We must also remember that many cultural shifts—including the normalization of abortion and the redefinition of marriage—are not just legal issues; they are moral ones. As Christians, we must speak truth without hate. Homosexuality, in my belief, is both a sin and a mental health disorder—but that doesn’t justify mistreatment or exclusion. Our duty is to tell the truth, love the individual, and refuse to be silenced.
In Canada today, even discussing these topics openly is controversial. But autonomy should not just mean financial freedom—it must also restore freedom of speech, freedom of conscience, and freedom of belief. If Alberta were to control its own destiny, it could reclaim those freedoms.
Lessons from Venezuela and Sodom
Look at Venezuela: when Chavez began nationalizing private businesses, it felt empowering to many—at first. But when responsibility disappeared, so did prosperity. The economy collapsed. Similarly, in the Bible, when Lot left Sodom and Gomorrah, the cities were burned to the ground. These stories are not just parables—they’re warnings.
God’s laws are not suggestions. They are blueprints for sustainable life. Whether you’re a policymaker, a business owner, or just someone trying to do the right thing—if you remove God from the equation, disorder will follow.
Final Thoughts
Albertan autonomy cannot succeed on money alone. It must be undergirded by faith, courage, and disciplined governance. That means building provincial police forces, managing pension systems locally, and standing firm in the face of political opposition. It also means returning to God, both individually and collectively.
The Ben Trudeau model emphasizes fiscal control—but autonomy also requires cultural confidence and spiritual clarity. Christians must read their Bibles, not just listen to pastors. We must discern truth in an age of noise and remind ourselves that real freedom begins within.
And yes—consider making Jesus Christ your Lord and Savior today.
